Showing posts with label Article. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Article. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

THE ROLES OF BEHAVIORISM THEORY IN LEARNING ENGLISH FOR THE BEGINNERS

THE ROLES OF BEHAVIORISM THEORY IN LEARNING ENGLISH FOR THE BEGINNERS

By Anselmus Sahan*

Part I
Introduction

Many countries over the world have been practicing the “Human Development” as a great project facing all decision makers. This human project is done in various ways in accordance with the basic needs of each nation or country. However, basically it is carried out because of some reasons as follows: Firstly, human beings have created many theories which are in fact useful for their lives, their relations with nature and/or other creatures. Those theories give reflection to human beings to feel that they are not the only creatures and therefore try to make this world full of friendship, joy and happiness. In the twentieth century, countries which do not care nature are blamed as the source of natural disasters. Actions to love nature particularly environment have become an integral part of human lives whenever and wherever they are.
Secondly, human development as a project has to empower the human beings as a central spot of this project. This can be manifested through educating human beings to love nature, to make real things to protect nature and/or environment, and to make humanism relations with other human beings across the areas and/or countries. Nowadays, there are three central issues addressed to the world society, namely: democratization, nature and gender. These three great issues can make people feel that each person has right, but there is no freedom to cut trees or burn the forest, and all women have the equal rights to do as the man do.



And finally, development is viewed as a progressive series of changes that occur in a predictable pattern as the result of an interaction between biological and environmental factors. In real life, to implement this view, education is regarded as the central institutions that can realize these three issues. Of course, education world which has curriculum in which all subjects are defined is a leading sector which can reach the aims of human development.

In line with the growth of population over the world, scientists try to develop at least four basic theories which discuss in detail the human being development, particularly in its implementation in education field. Those theories of human development are the Maturational Model, the Psychoanalytic Model, the Behavioral Model, and the Cognitive-Developmental Model (Salkind, 1985: 11-19).
The Maturational Model, developed by a physician, Gessel believes that the sequence of development is determined by the biological and evolutionary history of the species; or, development of the organism is essentially under the control of biological system and the process of maturation. Environment only acts in a supportive role. He adds that behavior at different stages of development has different degrees of balance and stability.

The Psychoanalytic Model, developed by Sigmund Freud, views that development is revolutionary in both its content and implication for the nature of development, consisting of dynamic, structural, and sequential components influenced by a continuously renewed need for the gratification of basic instincts. Psychic energy or energy of life is channeled through three different components or Freud’s tripartite system (the dynamic or economic component, the structural or topographical component, and the sequential or stage of component) that constitute the basis of the developmental process and individual differences. He adds that the dynamic or economic component characterizes the human mind (or psyche) as a fluid, energized system that can transfer energy from one part to the other where and when needed. The structural or topographical component describes the three separate, yet interdependent, psychological structures called id, ego, and superego and the way in which they regulate behavior. The sequential or stage of component emphasizes a progression from one stage of development to the next, focusing on different zones of bodily sensitivity (such as mouth) and accompanying psychological and social conflicts.

The Behavioral Model, developed by John Locke, et al views that development is a function of learning and one that proceeds according to certain laws or principles of learning. It places the major impetus for growth and development outside of the individual in the environment and organism is seen as reactive instead of active. The laws of learning and the influence of the environment paramount in the developmental process, covering classical conditioning and imitation. The newborn child as a naive and unlearned based on “Tabula Rasa” or “blank slate”. The Cognitive-Developmental Model: Stressing on the individual’s active rather than reactive role in the developmental process. Experience is the important factor in the developmental process.

The Cognitive-Developmental Model, developed by Ausubel and Sullivan, stresses the individual’s active rather than reactive role in the developmental process. Its basic assumptions are: (a) development occurs in a series of qualitatively distinct stages, (b) these stages always follow the same sequence, but do not necessarily occur at the same times for all individuals, (c) the stages are hierarchically organized such that a later stage subsumes the characteristics of an earlier one.

In addition, the presence of psychological structures and the way in which changes in these underlying structures are reflected in overt changes in behaviors. The form these changes take, depends on the individual’s developmental level. Development as a process qualitative differentiation or evolution of form, consisting of a series of sequence of orderly stages that are internally regulated, and that individual is transformed from one into the other.

However, this simple paper just wants to discuss the Behavioral Model, developed by John Locke, et al. I focus my discussion on this model because I think it is relevance with students who learn English in the beginning called beginner. I believe as beginners, they will find many difficulties to understand, for example, sounds, words and sentences, et cetera. Trough this model, teacher can help his students to slowly teach them to master English. Therefore, I can state the problem of my paper as follows: “How can the Behavioral Model help teacher to make learning situation for his students?”

To get the materials of the discussion I just read some books or references relevance with human development, education development, and models of human development theories. I believe those references have given inspiration to write this simple paper.
While to analyze the data gathered, I analyze them using the framework of the theories of human development. As stated in the problems of my paper, I analyze the data by reflecting some activities of the behavioral model practiced in teaching and elements of the model related to its strengths and weaknesses aimed at giving consideration to education practitioners of teaching not just to adopt this model and implement it in all classroom activities. What I want to share is that teacher may know this model and attempt to apply some relevance activities hoped that they can help students to learn English well.

Part II
Discussion

A. What is Behavioral Model?

John Locke, et al view that development is a function of learning and one that proceeds according to certain laws or principles of learning. This means that students’ intellectual development really exists in each student. To realize it, learning should function to provide him/her a chance to reach it. Something which is provided for student to learn, according to this model, is called stimulus (Salkind, 1985: 16-17).
In the same way, this model places the major impetus for growth and development outside of the individual in the environment and organism is seen as reactive instead of active. It means that if a learning activity provided some stimuli, student should give response to those stimuli. If the stimulus provided is responded, then it is viewed that learning is able to create a stimulus and response condition.

To realize and particularly to strengthen the work of stimulus and response, this model exposes the laws of learning and the influence of the environment which is paramount in the developmental process, covering classical conditioning and imitation. It indicates that the creation of condition in which stimulus and response may happen, is a prerequisite task. The creation of the condition is realized in forms of imitation activities. It believes that one difficult problem, if it is imitated from day to day or from time to time, will be easily solved and consequently be memorized its laws.

It seems that this model really trusts that the newborn child as a naive and unlearned is “Tabula Rasa” or “blank slate”. A child who is still small will be an adult and experience a new environment in which she/he learns new things, such as words learning. In the process of his/her physical and emotional developments, he will face ways how he/she adapts himself and adopt new formulas which might be useful for his/her life.
As the final proposal, it is believed that experience is the important factor in the developmental process. As previously stated that a child will grow in a new environment, learning new things and those will enrich his experience. Through those experiences he/she will learn ways to socialize and actualize him/herself in his environment. By involving him/herself in the environment he/she will experience the changes of his/her emotional (intelligence) conditions.

B. Skinner’s Behaviorism Theory

Beside John Locke, Burrhus Frederic Skinner, an influential American Psychologist, author, inventor, advocate for social reform and poet, also conducted pioneering work in psychology and innovated his own school of Radical Behaviorism. It seeks to understand behavior as a function of environmental histories of reinforcing consequences. He is known as the inventor of the operant conditioning chamber (or Skinner box), a research tool used to examine the orderly relations of the behavior of organisms (such as rats, pigeons and humans) to their environment (Salkind, 1985: 16-17 and 135-149).

He articulated the now widely accepted term reinforcement as a scientific principle of behavior. His position reflects the extension of the influence of physicist Ernst Mach’s The Science of Mechanics to the subject of psychology. Skinner’s pioneering research reflected the dual influence of whole organism research in Ivan Pavlov and Jacques Loeb.

Skinner invented the operant conditioning chamber which was used to measure organic responses and their orderly interactions with the environment. This device was an example of his lifelong ability to invent useful devices, which included whimsical devices in his childhood to the cumulative recorder to measure the rate of response of organisms in an operant chamber. Even in old age, Skinner invented a Thinking Aid to assist in writing.

The teaching machine was a mechanical device whose purpose was to administer a curriculum of programmed instruction. It housed a list of questions, and a mechanism through which the learner could respond to each question. Upon delivering a correct answer, the learner would be rewarded.

Finding the behaviorism of his time to be problematic, Skinner branched off his own version he called Radical Behaviorism which unlike methodological behaviorism did not require truth by consensus so it could accept private events such as thinking, perception and emotion in its account. Also, unlike all of the other behaviorists such as Tolman, Hull and Clark, Skinner’s version radically rejected mediating constructs and the hypothetico-deductive method, instead offering a strongly inductive, data driven approach that has proven to be successful in dozens of areas from behavioral pharmacology to language therapy in the developmentally delayed.

He is the author of Walden Two, Beyond the Freedom and Dignity, Verbal Behavior, Science and Human Behavior, and numerous other books and articles.

Challenged by Alfred North Whitehead during a casual discussion while at Harvard to provide an account of a randomly provided piece of verbal behavior Skinner set about attempting to extend his then-new functional, inductive, approach to the complexity of human verbal behavior. Developed over two decades, his work appeared as the culmination of the William James lectures in the book, Verbal Behavior. Although Noam Chomsky was highly critical of Verbal Behavior, he conceded that it was the “most careful and thoroughgoing presentation of such speculations” as a reason for giving it “a review.” After a slow reception, perhaps due to its lack of experimental evidence unlike Skinner’s previous work Skinner’s functional analysis of verbal behavior has seen a resurgence of interest in applied settings.

Skinner influenced education as well as psychology. He was quoted as saying, “Teachers must learn how to teach… they need only to be taught more effective ways of teaching.” Skinner asserted that positive reinforcement is more effective at changing and establishing behavior than punishment, with obvious implications for the then widespread practice of rote learning and punitive discipline in education. Skinner also suggests that the main thing people learn from being punished is how to avoid getting punished the next time.

Skinner says that there are 5 main obstacles in learning: (a) people have a fear of failure, (b) there is a lack of directions, (c) there is also a lack of clarity in the direction, (d) positive reinforcement is not used enough, and (e) the task is not broken down into small enough steps. Therefore, Skinner suggests that with all of the obstacles out of the way any age appropriate skill can be taught using his 5 principles: (a) have small steps, (b) work from most simple to most complex tasks, (c) repeat the directions as many times as possible, (d) give immediate feedback, and (e) give positive reinforcement.

Skinner’s views on education are extensively written about in his book The Technology of Teaching. It is also reflected in Fred S. Keller’s Programmed System of Instruction and Ogden R. Lidsley’s Precision Teaching.
In addition, part of Skinner’s analysis of behavior involved not only the power of a single instance of reinforcement, but the effects of particular schedules of reinforcement over time. Skinner’s types of schedules of reinforcement involved: interval (fixed or variable) and ratio (fixed or variable).

* Continuous reinforcement. It is a constant delivery of reinforcement for an action; every time a specific action was performed the subject instantly and always received a reinforcement. However, this method is prone to extinction and is very hard to enforce.
* Interval (fixed/variable) reinforcement. It is a fixed reinforcement which contains a set for certain times. Its variables are times between reinforcement although they are not set, and often differ.
* Ratio (fixed or variable) reinforcement. It is also fixed reinforcement which deals with a set amount of work needed to be completed before there is reinforcement. Its variable is amount of work needed for the reinforcement that differs from the last.

C. Application of Behaviorism Theory

The Behavioral Models both proposed by John Locke, et al and Skinner which deals with the changes of attitudes as the results of stimulus given set up some basic principles of its application in running a teaching and learning process, particularly to the beginner students who firstly learn English subject. These principles have potencies to change their behavior and force them to do the tasks given as seen in the following description.

1. Set up instructional objectives. The Behaviorism Model helps teacher to set up objectives of his teaching so that his students can follow learning process, understand the materials presented, and complete the tasks given. All tasks are formed through repetition drills and imitation. Before doing the tasks, teacher has provided a answer model and students should follows it. In the same way, teacher also provides some fixed forms of sentences and those require students to memorize and follow their teacher’s model of pronunciation.
2. Analyze current classroom environment, including identifying students’ ”entry behavior”. One of the most important duties teacher does in this model is that she/he should have competence to know a set of knowledge his students have before joining a certain topic. This is a prerequisite condition because by knowing this before, teacher can manage teaching and learning process well. To know students’ entry behavior, for example, teachers always prepares some questions (called leading questions) before presenting the materials of his teaching and asks those questions to students. If students can answer those questions, he/she may conclude that students have had knowledge about the topic he/she is going to teach. If not he should consider the best ways (in forms of exercises) to help them learn the materials given.
3. Establish learning materials (themes, topics, and sub topics). In this instance, for example, English subject taught to Junior High School Students, teacher establishes some topics and/or sub topics to be taught in one semester. Usually those topic and/or sub topics are provided in the Curriculum. But his tasks are to arrange some activities containing stimuli that might be helpful for increasing students’ motivation (responses) in learning those materials.
4. Divide learning materials into some topics and/or sub topics. Because the topics provided in the Curriculum book are of various topics, teacher should be able to divide them into some sub topics. This division will help him to set up priority scale in presenting the sub topics.
5. Present learning materials. After preparing the materials for teaching, now it is time for teacher to present them in the classroom. In presenting those materials, teacher should have extra abilities to enable his students to learn. It means that she/he should provide a set of exercises that require students to master the materials being given.
6. Give possible stimulus such as questions, test, exercises, and tasks or assignments. As stated before, in the beginning part of his teaching, teacher may offer some questions just to measure whether students have knowledge about the materials he/she will teach. Some kinds of questions may be also addressed in the middle and/or at the end of lesson. Usually, kinds of questions addressed in the middle and at the end of lesson aim to measure whether students have understood the materials being presented or not. If not, she/he will summarize the materials and give home assignment. In the same way, at the ending part of lesson, teacher can give them test, exercises and/or tasks to complete individually or in group. These have the same aim with the questions but need a lot of time to think and find out the answers.
7. Monitor and analyze responses addressed. While students do the tasks given, teacher can monitor students’ activities and try to analyze why they are really active, why some of them are passive, or why there are some groups which can complete the tasks fast while others not.
8. Give reinforcement (may be positive or negative reinforcement). Usually reinforcement is given at the ending part of lesson. In this time, teacher assigns students some exercises aimed at measuring students’ comprehension.
9. Give new stimulus. In this step, teacher provides some exercises which are mostly the same as the materials being given. For example, the topic of teaching English today is “Present Tense”. To help his students, teacher provides some sentences related to Present Tense and asks them to make negative forms, questions and short answers. But at the ending part of lesson, teacher distributes an article copied from English magazine and asks students to underline some Present Tense Sentences in the article. This is called new stimulus.
10. Monitor and analyze responses given (evaluate learning achievements). Monitor appears in form of observing students responses during presenting the materials or completing the exercises given. Of course, it aims to know students’ participation and activity. At the same time, particularly after completing a task, teacher revises their answers and finds that there are still some students who get low marks. By the fact, he plans to prepare a new stimulus.
11. Give reinforcement. Giving reinforcement is actually the realization of teacher’s findings that there are some students whose marks are still under the passing standard. Therefore, he offers another type of exercise aiming to reinforce their knowledge about the materials given. Usually, the more teacher gives exercises, the more students understand the materials.

Part III
Conclusion and Suggestion

A. Conclusions

There are two conclusions that I can draw from the description about the Behavioral Model above as presented as follows:

1. Almost the same as Scaffolding proposed by a Russian psychologist, Vygostky, the Behavioral Model that delivers Behaviorism Theory, is a model of learning that can be implemented in the situation where most students in a class are new learners or beginners; that is, those who firstly learn a new language, for example, English. Using the behavioral Model, teacher can motivate them to learn and master the language.
2. To practice this model in teaching and learning process, teacher should be wise because it will take much time and effort to guide beginners to master English. By using repetition and imitation exercises, learners are trained to master many parts of the language being learnt.

B. Suggestions

1. Teacher should prepare the materials for his teaching so that his learners can master he language being learnt.
2. Teacher should be wise to encounter learners difficulties in learning English.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This simple writing is a final task submitted to the Lecturer of The Theories of Language Learning Subject, Prof. Sulis. It consists of three parts: Introduction, Discussion, and Conclusion and Suggestion.
As a God creature, in the first I would like to thank to Almighty God for this blessing and invariably help showing during my life, particularly doing this simple paper writing. I also recognize that many people have contributed a lot of ideas to him. Therefore, through this great opportunity, I want to express my gratitude appreciation to some of them as follows:
1. Former lecturer of Theories of Language Learning Subject, Prof. A. Maryanto, Ph.D (the late) who has poured on my mind many current theories of language learning which, I think, are very important to support my study.
2. Prof. Sulis, the successor of Prof. Maryanto, who has assigned me, including my classmates, to write a simple paper related the theories of language learning. This assignment is a motivator for me to write in English and it is viewed a great chance for me to improve my ability in English.
3. My classmates who have, by their unique attitude, supported me to learn together from day to day and I feel, I am really at home with them because we can share our knowledge and experiences each other.
Finally, I should state that I do not have much money to pay back their sacrifice. I just pray to God to bless and protect them.
REFERENCES

Ahmadi, A. and Joko Tri Prasetya. 1997. Strategi Belajar Mengajar untuk Fakultas Tarbiyah, Komponen MKDK. Bandung: Pustaka Setia.

Buchori, M. 1995. Transformasi Pendidikan. Jakarta: Pustaka Sinar Harapan and IKIP Muhammadiyah Press.

Purwanto, M. N. 1994. Ilmu Pendidikan Teoritis dan Praktis. Bandung: Rosdakarya.

Rusyan, A. T, et. al. 1989. Pendekatan dalam Proses Belajar Mengajar. Bandung: Remadja Karya.

Siagian, S. P. 1994. Filsafat Administrasi. Jakarta: Haji Masagung.

Soetjipto and Raflis Kosasi. 2004. Profesi Keguruan. Jakarta: Rineka Cipta.

Suhartono. 2008. Filsafat Pendidikan. Jogjakarta: Ruzz Media.

Tilaar, H. A. R and Riant Nugroho. 2008. Kebijakan Pendidikan, Pengantar untuk Memahami Kebijakan Pendidikan dan Kebijakan Pendidikan sebagai Kebijakan Publik. Yogyakarta: Pustaka Pelajar.

Tilaar, H. A. R. 2001. Manajemen Pendidikan Nasional, Kajian Pendidikan Masa Depan. Bandung: Remaja Rosdakarya Offset.

Tirtarahardja, U. and La Sula. 2000. Pengantar Pendidikan. Jakarta: Rineka Cipta.

Usman, M. U. 1995. Menjadi Guru Profesional. Bandung: Rosda Karya Offset.

Salkind, N. J. 1985. Theories of Human Development, second edition. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Brown. H. D. 2001. Teaching by Principles, An Interactive Approach to Language Pedagogy, Second edition. New York: Addison Wesley Longman, Inc.

*POSTGRADUATE PROGRAM, ENGLISH STUDIES PROGRAM, SEMARANG STATE UNIVERSITY, SEMARANG

Read More...

Saturday, March 28, 2009

DISCOURSE ANALYSIS

DISCOURSE ANALYSIS

ANSELMUS SAHAN

To understand discourse analysis, I start with some leading questions. Through those questions, I can get a gateway to go in detail description about discourse analysis, its significance in learning and its programs to help readers or students, including all of us, know more it. In the first part, I raise three questions related the concept of discourse analysis, its unit of analysis, its tools keeping its data base, and the way discourse analysts regard the issue of objectivity-subjectivity and the quantitative-qualitative approaches to data collection and analysis.
The first question I should raise is “What is discourse analysis? Allwright (1991: 61) defines discourse analysis as variety of procedures for examining chunks of language, whether spoken or written. In the case of classroom research, it usually involves the analysis of spoken language as it is used in classrooms among teachers and learners. While Van Lier (1988: 22) describes it as an analysis of the process of interaction by means of a close examination of audiovisual records of interaction. However, in fact, it deals with many analytical processes, from coding and quantification to more qualitative interpretations.



What do discourse analysts typically examine as units of analysis, and what do they use as their data base? Discourse analysts typically use transcripts and audiotaped or video-taped interactions as their data base.
What is meant by “transcript”, and how important is it in discourse analysis? Transcript is written record of interaction in which researcher copies down, verbatim, the utterances of the participants. In fact, transcripts vary widely in their level of technical complexity. They may use standard orthography or detailed phonetic representations of speech, depending on the research goal. They are important in discourse analysis because, they show us, in ways that coded data and frequent count often mask, how classroom interaction develops, as a dynamic phenomenon. Therefore, many classroom researchers prefer to conduct discourse analyses with detailed transcripts, rather than using other data collection procedures which may be easier to do, but which also run the risk of obscuring important information.
And the last question is “How do discourse analysts regard the issue of objectivity-subjectivity and the quantitative-qualitative approaches to data collection and analysis?” Discourse analysts regard the issues of objectivity-subjectivity in term of collecting and recording classroom data. For example: In constructing such instruments, researchers distinguish between ‘low inference’ and ‘high inference’ categories of analysis. Low inference categories include things that can be counted or coded without the observer having to infer very much, while high inference demand that the observer make a judgment that goes well beyond what is immediately visible. In addition, discourse analysts regard the issues of quantitative-qualitative approaches to data collection and analysis as ways to analyze data that have been gathered or collected. The data can be quantified, as when an observer counts the frequency of certain behaviors (hand raising, for instance) or when researcher uses learners’ test scores as an outcome measure in a process-product study. After quantifying the qualitative data, researchers can easily count, analyze and interpret the data.

In the second part, I expose five questions related to five ranks of classroom discourse according to Sinclair and Coulthard, two analytical levels and its contain, types of move identified by Bellack (1966) and Fanselow (1977), kinds of acts constitute each move, and specific areas of L2 discourse analysis suggested by Chaudron (1977) and Tsui (1985).
The five ranks of classroom discourse according to Sinclair and Coulthard are lesson, transaction, exchange (boundary and teaching), move (opening, answering, follows-up, framing, and focusing), and act.
What are the two analytical levels, and what does each level contain? The two analytical levels of discourse are the linguistic level of sentential analysis and social/ pedagogical level of programs and courses. The discourse level is comprised of five ranks (lesson, transaction, exchange, move and act), each of which constitutes the elements of the rank, according to rank-specific structural rules. While social/pedagogical level consists of various structures, which are realized by “acts,” each having a specific discourse function.
How many types of move are identified by Bellack (1966) and Fanselow (1977), and what are they called? There are five types of move: opening move, answering move, follows-up move, framing move, and focusing move.
What kinds of acts constitute each move, and how are they further classified? Head act and adjunct act constitute each element of move and are further classified into three kinds: head, pre-head and post-head acts.
What are the specific areas of L2 discourse analysis suggested by Chaudron (1977) and Tsui (1985)? Briefly explain five of them! They are structural units (consisting of utterance, turn, turn-unit, communication unit, and fragment) and functional units (covering repetition, expansion, clarification request, comprehension check, confirmation check, repair, and model). Utterance is a string of speech by one speaker under a single intonation contour, and preceded and followed by another speaker’s speech, or a pause of more than x seconds. Turn is any speaker’s sequence of utterances bounded by another speaker’s speech. Turn-unit is any syntactic main clause and its associated subordinate clauses. Communication unit is an independent grammatical prediction; the same as a Turn-unit, except that in oral language, elliptical answers to questions also constitute complete predications. Fragment is any utterance which does not constitute a completed proposition (i.e., which explicit subject and verb).
In the last part, I address ten questions covering three reasons why a study of turn taking is significant in L2 research, four basic principles of turn taking and its principle, the ways turns can be classified on the basis of their functional distinction, some terms related turn taking, concept of topic as used in discourse analysis, topic regarded as a unit of analysis and as part of a discourse process, topic and activity, the importance of repair in learner’s language development, and kinds of actions or ideas covered by the broadly-defined repair.
Give three reasons why a study of turn taking is significant in L2 research! First, classroom activities are determined by the forces (usually the teacher, but also tacit norms of classroom conduct) that govern allocation of turns elaborating control over proceeding, including topics and types of activities, that co-occurs and coincides with control over turn taking. Second, under a rigid control situation of teacher, learners will not able to explore the ways in which speaker change is effected through turn taking in the target language. Consequently, they can not practice vital skills involved in interacting in the target language. And third, the conversational turn-taking organization provides ‘an intrinsic motivation for listening’. In its turn-allocational techniques, the turn-taking system for conversation builds in an intrinsic motivation for listening to all utterances in a conversation, independent of other possible motivations, such as interest and politeness.
Based on the three situations above, I can say that observation in L2 classroom activities contains three reasons. Firstly, the chances of learning language are greatly improved if the learners pay close attention and comprehension to the language they hear around them. Secondly, it is also a great chance for less attention and competent learners to learn form their friends or mates and/or follow he ways their teacher motivates them to pay attention and involve seriously in turn-taking activities that finally may improve their ability. And thirdly, conversational turn-taking forces participants to be actively involved, and to plan and structure their contribution in contextually appropriate and acceptable ways.
What are the four basic principles of turn taking and what is each principle particularly about? The four basic principles of turn taking are transition, distribution, prominence, and initiative. Transition particularly covers turn progression and turn size; distribution particularly deals with speaker selection and allocation; prominence is about the status of a turn as attended-to-action; and initiative correlates with voluntary (i.e. actor-originated) participation in the goings on. In practical level, initiative is used by the would-be-next speaker, or else the next speaker has been selected through turn allocation. Prominence is obtained, either by virtue of initiative, or through loudness, or non –verbal behaviour, or other attention-getting factors. The turn is proceeding now, initiative and prominence having been achieved. Its rough length is staked out, if necessary by projecting the various chunks, turn claims are countered by turn-claim suppression signals; the focus is on orderly progression, working towards orderly transition. And turn is coming to an end and, if appropriate, content and/or speaker of next turn are indicated.
How can turns be classified on the basis of their functional distinction? By the dynamics of speaker change in an interaction. The turns can be classified into four ways:
Prospective is the way the turn is linked (through turn-taking devices) to (the) subsequent turn(s). The turn influences the subsequent turn(s) by constraining content, or by delimiting next speakership.
Retrospective is the way the turn is linked (through turn-taking devices) to (the) proceeding turn(s).
Concurrent is a turn that is taken during a current turn which is related to that turn in a servicing sense.
Neutral is a turn which indeterminate as prospective, retrospective, and concurrent, and which is not implicative of prospective or retrospective relations to its surrounding turns.
Explain each of the following terms: nominating, giving way, floor seeking, intra-turn repair, and rehearsal!
Nominating is a subpart of allocating prospective which verbally selects a next speaker by giving a name description or pronoun (“you here’).
Giving way is subpart of allocating prospective which occurs when a speaker stops short before the projected completion of his/her turn in order to give way to competition, i.e. when another speaker has ‘interrupted’ or as a result of simultaneous starts.
Floor seeking or self-selecting is subpart of allocating prospective which occurs when a participant begins a turn during another speaker’s turn.
Intra-turn repair/repair-initiation is a subpart of allocating prospective which, together with listening responses, occurs during a turn and is related to the current turn in a subservient capacity. Intra-turn repair/repair-initiation includes brief requests for clarification, replacements of errors, and also instances of prompting and helping.
Rehearsal together with private turns may comment on other (concurrent or preceding) turns or use items in them for personal trial purposes. Comments may also be addressed to another (usually neighbouring) learner or a small subset of learner, relating to the main business of the moment or to other business, usually delivered in a soft voice.
What is your understanding of the term “topic” as is used in discourse analysis? Topic is a unit of analysis of discourse which covers what is involving doing and what it is about. In daily interaction, it can be found that every interaction can be characterized into two basic ways: what kind of activity it is, i.e. what it involves doing, and what it is about, i.e. topic.
Topic can be regarded as a unit of analysis and as part of a discourse process. Explain the difference! In second language classroom research, topic is viewed from two ways: as a unit of analysis and as part of discourse process. In the first sense, a lesson can divided into topics in the same way that a conversation can be divided into topics. For example, the topics of a lesson might be the homework, a dialogue about asking the way, a presentation of Wh-questions, pair work using a map of the city, a role play at the airport, etc. While a unit of analysis is a subpart of a discourse process which deals with the subdivision parts of a discourse process. In other words, topic consists of some units of analysis and the units of analysis as parts of discourse constitute the existence of discourse process.
Do you think topic and activity are dependent or independent on one another? Give your reason! Both are dependent on one another. First, topic is the realization of the question what it is about, while activity answers the question of what involves in doing something. Seen form this relationship, it seems that activity is the application of topic. And second, in a conversation, the activity of ‘small talk’ limits severely the range of issues that can be used for topics, and this will vary considerably across cultures and social groups.
How is “repair” important in the learner’s language development? By identifying and repairing the learner’s errors in learning the target language. The learner’s errors are data that show to the teacher and/or researcher about the learner’s discrepancies in learning a foreign language and that they have to repair the errors so that the learner may experience progress in her/his foreign or target language learning.
What kinds of actions or ideas may be covered by the broadly-defined “repair”? The broadly-defined “repair” at least covers three ideas: error correction, treatment of trouble occurring in interactive language use, and problems of speaking, hearing, and understanding the talk.
Repair can be medium-oriented, message-oriented, or activity-oriented. Give an example of each!
Medium-oriented is a kind of repair activities in L2 classroom which focuses on the forms and/or functions of the target language, for example, learners tend to ‘while you have a bath’ instead of “while you were having (taking) a bath’, and ‘and you and you was having a bath’ instead of ‘and you were having a bath’.
Message-oriented is a kind of repair activities in L2 classroom which focuses on the transmission of thoughts, information, feelings, for example: ‘what do you think is the main problem in the future” and the answer is “in the future . . . ‘. It should be answered completely “I’m thinking about a job that can earn much money’. This may be stimulated by his/her teacher and/or friends.
activity-oriented is a kind of repair activities in L2 classroom which focuses on the organization and structure of the classroom environment, rules for the conduct of activities. For example, when a teacher asks student “Ok Joko, how many books am I holding?” The student might be able to count and say ‘four’, for instance, but he is not sure to his own answer. To lead Joko to the right answer, the teacher should mention ‘four’ while asking him whether he agrees with his teacher or not.

REFERENCES
Allwright, D. and K. M. Bailey. 1991. Focus on the language classroom. Cambirdge: Cambirdge University Press.
Chaudron, C. 1988. Second language classrooms: Research on teaching and learning. Cambirdge: Cambridge University Press.
Nunan, D. 1992. Research methods in language learning. Cambirdge: Cambirdge University Press.
Runcie, J. F. 1980. Experiencing social research. Ontario: The Dorcey Press.
Sinclair, J. M. and M. Coulthard. 1975. Towards an analysis of discourse. London: Oxford University Press.
van Lier, L. 1988. The classroom and language learner. London: Longman.
Saleh, M. 2008. Enam tradisi besar penelitian pendidikan bahasa. Semarang: Unnes Press.

Read More...

Sunday, February 8, 2009

TEACHER’S COMPETENCE

TEACHER’S COMPETENCE AND STUDENTS’ ACHIEVEMENT
Anselmus Sahan
Lecturer of Writing and Literature
Timor University, Kefamenanu, Timor, East Nusa Tenggara Province
I am also a student of Postgraduate Program, English Studies Program, Semarang State University


ABSTRACT
This paper just tries to poor down my understanding on the relationship between teacher competence and students’ achievement. To evaluate this relationship, it analyzes the concepts of competence, teacher competence, and the influences of teacher competence to increase the students’ achievement. It is hoped, it will be an alternative way to reflect us as teachers to do our job professionally.

KEY WORDS:
Teacher Competence and Students’ Achievement



Introduction
Form year to year, an issue around the results of the final examination in Indonesia has become a national debate. This issue is exposed to surface whenever the results of the final examination are really disappointing many sides, particularly students’ parents. To some extent, arguments coming from education experts and practitioners blame that the low achievement is caused by lack of trained teachers, low financial support from the government and low discipline to learning at certain schools. On the contrary, others argue that it is influenced by lack of preparation from students’ themselves. They never try to learn at home or at school although some schools have adequate facility.
Understanding the main cause of the low achievement means thinking about the solution of how to overcome that problem so that we, as members of this nation, may change the discourse on the final examination results; rather talking much about the central figures that can help students to pass on the final examination. The change of our attitude to respect and consider to the existence of the central figures in education is an indication of a radical shift on our mind.
We know that, as teachers, our main aim of our job is to make students learn effectively and efficiently. For doing so, a teacher has to do several activities such as plan properly, provide effective instruction and evaluate the learning activities using appropriate methods and techniques. That means that a teacher has to perform a host of activities inside and outside the classroom. We also know that effectiveness or ineffectiveness of teaching is closely linked to teacher competence. Competent teacher would create classroom conditions and climate, which are conducive for student learning.
Education experts, in general, agree that there are three factors that influence the success of teaching and learning process. Those interrelated factors are social, school, and family environments. However, based on my own experience, one of the school components, that is, teachers, play an important role in succeeding and helping students to get good achievement. As teachers, we should accept many criticisms addressed to us that we are actually not able to handle our job professionally. We are just proud that as teachers we are always greeted by many students, including people outside the school. But we never think and realize that many people are clever because of us, teachers. And, because of that case, we have to try to evaluate ourselves, to reflect whether we have really done our best.
Some teachers when asked their comments about the low final achievement last year, they claimed that it was due to the lack of preparation of the students. They refused to amend that that is caused by their low preparation on their students.
Richards (2006: 5) in talking about “The Roles of Teachers and Learners” in the Classroom of Communicative Language Teaching Today argues that learners now had to participate in classroom activities that were based on a cooperative rather than individualistic approach to learning. Students had to become comfortable with listening to their peers in group work or pair work tasks, rather than relying on the teacher for a model. And teachers now had to assume the role of facilitator and monitor. Rather than being a model for correct speech and writing and one with the primary responsibility of making students produce plenty of error-free sentences, the teacher had to develop a different view of learners’ errors and of her/his own role in facilitating language learning.
Brown (2001: 200-202) in Teaching by Principles, An Interactive Approach to Language Pedagogy, particularly in talking about teacher’s roles and styles, acknowledges that a teacher has to play many roles. Think of the possibilities: authority figure, leader, knower, director, manager, counselor, guide, and even such roles as friend, confidante, and parent. Depending on the country your are in, on the institution in which you are teaching, on the type of course, and on the makeup of your students, some of these roles will be more prominent than others, especially in the eyes of your students.
For growing comfortable and confident in playing multiple roles, teachers should have a willing acceptance of many ways that students will perceive you, and a consistent fairness to all students equally. Know ourselves, limitations, strengths, likes, and then accept the fact that we are called upon to be many things to many different people. Then, as we become more comfortable with say, being an authority figure, be consistent in all your dealings with students. There is something quite unsettling about a teacher who is a sympathetic friend to some students and a dispassionate authority figure to others. Such waffling in playing out your roles can set students against each other, with many feeling shut out from an inner circle of “teacher’s pets”.
Harmer (2007) in How to Teach English, particularly in describing good teachers states that most people can look back at their own schooldays and identify teacher they thought were good. But generally they find it quite hard to say why certain teachers struck them as special. Perhaps it was because of their personality. Possibly it was because they had interesting things to say. Maybe the reason was that they looked as if they loved their job, or perhaps their interest in their students’ progress was compelling. Sometimes, it seems, it was just because the teacher was a fascinating person!
One of the reasons that it is difficult to give general descriptions of good teachers is that different teachers are often successful in different ways. Some teachers are more extrovert or introvert than others, for example, and different teachers have different strengths and weaknesses. A lot will depend, too, on how students view individual teachers and here again, not all students will share the same opinions.
It is often said that ‘good teachers are born, not made’ and it does seem that some people have a natural affinity for the job. But there are also others, perhaps, who do not have what appears to be a natural gift but who are still effective and popular teachers. Such teachers learn their craft through a mixture of personality, intelligence, knowledge and experience (and how they reflect on it). And even some of the teachers who are apparently ‘born teachers’ weren’t like that at the beginning at all, but grew into the role as they learnt their craft.
I think, teaching is not an easy job, but it is a necessary one that can be very rewarding when we see our students’ progress and know that we have helped to make it happen. It is true that some lessons and students can be difficult and stressful at times, but it is also worth remembering that at its best teaching can also be extremely enjoyable.
Van Lier (1990: 38) in Brumfit and Mitchell (eds) when dealing with the discussion of Truth and Causality of Classroom Research argues “ … a simple causal view is inappropriate in classroom research for one every uncontroversial reason, namely, that teaching does not cause learning.” According to him, many times learning takes place without teaching, and, perhaps, equally often, the teaching event is not followed by a learning event. Quoting von Humboldt’s statement, he adds “ … many years ago teaching language was not possible, one could only create the conditions for learning to be possible. Lest the attentive readers reply that teaching is no more than creating the conditions that cause learning”.
Other experts view that teachers’ competence is sometimes not the representative of their educational level. Bartels (1999: 46-47) states that there is an evidence that teacher education does not work by ‘transferring’ appropriate knowledge to student teachers or by imposing a proper model of language and language teaching, but by interacting with the knowledge of each student teacher to form new individual knowledge structures. In the same way, Gutiersez Almarza (1996: 69) in Bartels (1999), based on her study of four language teachers in a one-year teacher certification program, concludes that “ … at the end of the course, they left with different kinds of knowledge about the dynamics of teaching and learning languages. To a considerable extent these variations were rooted in their pertaining knowledge.”
Her statements want to underline that teacher education should not be a question of imposing traditional or progressive teaching models on student teachers. It should be about establishing connections with the student teachers’ personal understanding and building on their knowledge. In order to do that, there must be more understanding of the kinds of knowledge teachers and teacher students have.
Omaggio (1986: 427-430) in Teaching Language in Context, Proficiency-Oriented Instruction, when talking about “Student Perceptions of Teacher Effectiveness: Some Research Results” reports that in one study of student attitudes (Omaggio, 1982), the results of his research clearly and emphatically indicated that those teachers who personalized their classrooms most were judged most effective by students and supervisors alike. The high correlations between amount of personalized talk and rank order in teacher effectiveness ratings showed that students judged such teachers significantly better than their peers judged teachers whose classrooms were neutral environments. In comments solicited from the end-of-semester evaluation forms, it was clear that the most appreciated aspects of the personalized classroom environment included such things as opportunities to converse with others, instructors’ warmth and personal interest, and the general interest and variety of activities. Students whose teachers failed to personalize to any significant extent complained that classes were generally dull, followed a stale routine, and gave them little opportunity for real conversation.
Malik et al (2003: 521-522) in their study about the Competency of University Teachers at the University of Agriculture, Faisalabad, found out their views regarding the competence being possessed by the teachers and suggestions for its enhancement, that students were well aware of the component out s needed and those possessed by their teachers. They suggested that the teachers must not only possess latest knowledge, but also be sympathetic, regular, punctual, friendly and free from any prejudice.
It seems that the importance of a teacher in an educational system cannot be stressed too far both from the students and national points of view on supreme task of promoting national ideal and building up national character of strong foundation falls. According to Kakkar (2001) in Malik (2003), the teacher of today is not a mere purveyor of lessons in a classroom. He is instead an individual who is of course not only interested in children acquire knowledge and skills but also equally involved in his total development. Keeping in view the importance of a teacher more than that mentioned above, an ideal teacher is expected to possess some attributes like proficiency in the subject, moral health, physical and mental fitness, professional training and devotion to the profession so that he may have an exemplary personality and out look for the students.
Proficiency in the subject, physical fitness and moral health of the teacher have been identified as the most important qualifications in addition to the professional training. That is why an utmost effort is made to select such persons as teachers who are fully competent for the performance of duties as teacher. In this regard Sorenson (1984) in Malik et all (2003) was of the view that all teachers at all levels should be strongly competent in the subjects they teach and must have sound body of knowledge about the students’ physiology and psychology. While presenting Islamic point of view states that the teacher has to follow the role and sayings of the Holy Prophet (PBUH) for being an effective teacher because the teaching is blessing and privilege in the Islamic society. In the light of above mentioned deliberations, it goes without saying that in addition to mastery of subject matter, sufficient professional training is also required to communicate information and knowledge to the students effectively.
Crow and Crow (1991) in Malik et al (2003) have placed increasing emphasis upon the basic areas of competence which include mastery of subject matter, understanding of human nature, interest in continued professional improvement, knowledge of availability to apply the principles of teaching etc. In this regard, they suggested that real reward of true teacher lies in the deep satisfaction, he feels in watching students grow in their understanding of themselves and of their world, in seeing them develop self-reliance, initiative and sense of responsibility and at observing their learning of facts, skills, habits and attitudes that are involved in becoming constructive citizens in a modern world.
Now, it becomes clear that keeping mastery of subject aside, the professional training is must to handle students and maintain proper discipline through effective teaching-learning skills. However, in developing countries particularly in Indonesia this important aspect is given least consideration while considering competencies required for University teachers. Thereby, a survey was conducted to determine the views of selected students of the University of Agriculture, Faisalabad with regard to the teachers’ effectiveness and competencies.
Padwad and Dixit (2008) in their paper entitled Impact of Professional Learning Community Participation on Teachers' Thinking about Classroom Problems believe that teacher education seems to exhibit a shift from product-oriented mode to social constructivist, process-oriented mode of working. The emergence of professional learning communities (PLCs) of teachers may be seen as one manifestation of this shift. PLCs are increasingly seen as an effective channel for teacher learning and professional development.
Classrooms, the sites of educational business, are often metaphorically equated to battlefields, where teacher-soldiers have to wage a war of education against all odds. Classrooms are sites riddled with innumerable problems, and teachers are those who have to face them immediately and directly. The success of the war depends on how effectively these problems are dealt with. This requires, on the one hand, minimizing the occurrence of problems, and on the other, equipping teachers to confront them effectively. Teacher education is usually concerned with the latter, and seeks a clear focus on continuous professional development. One popular and prevalent way of addressing this has been organizing training programs, short courses, and academic sessions that are normally "one-off" events.


Discussion
Teacher Competence
I think it is time now to talk much about the teachers competence as a shelter of teacher professionalism in doing their holy job, teaching, that has been proven from time to time as ‘doctors of education’ and will be hoped as the actors of changes to human development all over the world. The belief on teachers competence is not a sudden event, but it provides an axiom “without teachers, we are useless”. This axiom reminds us all to think that teachers are certain people who have certain competency to guide students so that they will have certain competencies as needed wherever, whenever, and however they are and whatever they will do.
Competence here is conceptualized in terms of types of knowledge and aspects of practice. Each competence is further analyzed into constituents. For instance, under ‘can demonstrate knowledge of theoretical approaches to language and language learning’ there are five elements, one of which is ‘can understand that recent approaches to language teaching view language as a socio-cultural meaning system’; this is in turn supported by the performance indicators ‘identifies the main features of spoken and written language as social interactive processes’ and examples. Strong and Hogan (1994: 10) in Bartels (1999) point out that the advantages of setting forth a statement on competence include the provision of a common language of skills and knowledge across the various teaching sectors’ and the preservation of existing gains in standards and the alignment of the profession.
Competency is a term used extensively by different people in different contexts. So it is defined in different ways. Teacher education and job performance of a teacher are the contexts in which this term is used. Competencies are the requirements of a competency based teacher education, which includes knowledge, skills and values the trainee teacher must demonstrate for successful completion of the teacher education program. A few characteristics of a competency are (1) a competency consists of one or more skills whose mastery would influence the its attainment, (2) a competency has its linkage with all the three domains under which performance can be assessed, covering the domains of knowledge, skill and attitude, (3) competencies are observable and demonstrable, and (4) because the competencies are observable, they are also measurable and assessable a competency from the performance of a teacher. It is not necessary that all competencies of a teacher have the same extent of knowledge, skill and attitude.
There may be some competencies of a teacher which have the same extent of knowledge, skill and attitude. There maybe some competencies involving more of knowledge than skill and attitude, whereas, some competencies may be skill/performance loaded. You know that there are a large number of instructional and related activities to be performed by the teacher inside and outside the classroom. These activities are of varied types. The effective organization of these activities would require that a teacher possesses a certain amount of knowledge and also certain attitudes and skills. This is known as teacher competence. In other words, teacher competence refers to "the right way of conveying units of knowledge, application and skills to students". The right way here includes knowledge of content, processes, methods and means of conveying content.
Any definition of teacher competence depends on teaching in a particular setting, the culture and values held in the community. It also depends on the innumerable teacher and student characteristics and the classroom context. Nevertheless, in order to know if we possess the necessary competencies in a given situation, we have to be judged on the basis of our ability to produce certain effects. But, there are as many ways of being effective as there are effects. Moreover, there could be disagreement even amongst ourselves over the effects that a teacher is expected to produce. It calls for value judgments and decisions as to how we with to view teaching. The research studies conducted so far indicate that there does not exist a single set of competencies which all the effective teachers possess or all the ineffective ones lack. We should collect information regarding when, how, who and what the purpose of each competency is most likely to be useful to. In other words, the concept of teacher competence is highly situational one and involves value judgments when one absolute set of competencies is effective in relation to all kinds of learner groups. There are many different sets that are relevant.
There seem to be different ways of classifying teacher competencies. One has to look at it in terms of teacher functions. Essentially, teachers have two major roles in the classroom: (i) to create the conditions under which learning can take place i.e. the social side of teaching and (ii) to impart, by a variety of means, 'knowledge' to their learners - the task oriented side of teaching. The first we could term as the 'enabling' or management function and the second, the instructional function. These complement each other as the latter would be, more or less impossible without the former. In practice, it is very difficult to separate the two and often, one performs both functions simultaneously.
Hargreaves (1983) in Bartels (1999: 64) in a discussion of ITT claims that teacher trainees are primarily concerned with ‘what I do when … ’ type issues. In the same paper he suggests that five types of issue relating to professional knowledge and performance are of interest to teachers. They are (1) class management: The teacher’s authority, and the ability to control and organize the classroom, (2) Pedagogy: The content and the methods of a lesson, involving selection, presentation, sequence and pace, (3) Continuity and coherence: The link between lessons to make up a course …; links between subjects: links between year groups …, (4) School structures and cultures: The structure of the whole curriculum and how it is allocated between groups: staff cultures and styles of working, and (5) The school in the context of the educational system: The different types of school and the interrelationships and relations with other aspects of the education system as a whole.
Leung and Teasdale in Lomax and McGrath (1999: 57) in their paper entitled ESL Teacher Competence: Professional Education and the Nature of Professional Knowledge report that educational achievement has been a primary focus of British educational policy since the mid 1980s. The introduction of a National Curriculum for schools is part of a larger strategy which includes setting benchmarks in order to raise educational standards. The Department for Education and Employment has published (DIEE, 1997) new standards for Qualified Teacher Status as well as English and Mathematics curricula for the initial training of primary teachers. It is understood that these standards and curricula will be extended to cover the secondary phase in the near future.
Teacher competence as a concept changes over time. For instance, Troman (1996) in Leung and Teasdale (1999: 59) traces the shifts in the official construction of the ‘good’ primary school teacher in England over a period of twenty years. In the late 1970s the idea of the generalist primary teachers was reshaped to highlight three qualities: the ability to match curriculum standards to children’ potentials, the ability to differentiate work according to the range of children’s abilities according to common principles, and the ability to draw on subject expertise.
Strevens (1977: 21-22) in New Orientation in the Teaching of English views that the general effectiveness of language training and teaching in any given country is heavily dependent on the nature and quality of the training which teachers undergo before entering their profession. Just as there is a great range of different kinds of learners, different aims, different standards of achievement, so there exists also a great range of teacher training courses. Nevertheless, it is possible to attempt a set of generalizations which embody the essential variables.
Training a teacher entails the selection of potentially suitable individuals (and by implication, the elimination of unsuitable applicants); the continuing personal education of the trainee so that the teacher can be seen to be a member of the educated sector of the community; general training as a teacher irrespective of specialization; and special training a s language teacher.
Brown (2001: 166-168) in Teaching by Principles, An Interactive Approach to Language Pedagogy in discussing “Interactive Language Teaching I: Initiating Interaction” states that teachers can play many roles in the course of teaching. Just as parents are called upon to be many things to their children, teachers cannot be satisfied with only one role. Quoting Rebecca Oxford et al. (1988), he points out that teacher roles are often best described in the form of metaphor: teacher as manufacturer, teacher a doctor, teacher as judge, teacher as gardener, and others.
He then suggests that as teachers we will find another set of metaphors to describe a spectrum of possibilities of teacher roles, some of which are more conducive to creating an interactive classroom than others. The metaphors related to the teacher’s job are described as follows. Firstly, teacher as controller. A role that is sometimes expected in traditional educational institutions is that of ‘master’ controller, always in charge of every moment in the classroom. Master controllers determine what the students do, when they should speak, and what language forms they should use. They can often predict many student responses because everything is mapped out ahead of time, with no leeway for divergent paths. In some respects, such control may sound admirable. But for interaction to take place, the teacher must create a climate in which spontaneity can thrive, in which unrehearsed language can be performed, and in which the freedom of expression given over the students makes it impossible to predict everything that they will say and do.
Nevertheless, some control on your part is actually an important element of successfully carrying out interactive techniques. In the planning phase especially, a wise controller will carefully project how a technique will proceed, map out the initial input to students, specify directions to be given, and gauge the timing of a technique. So, granted that allowing for spontaneity of expression involves yielding certain elements of control to students, nevertheless, even in the most cooperative of interactive classrooms, the teacher must maintain come control simply to organize the class hour.
Secondly, teacher as director. Some interactive classroom time can legitimately be structured in such a way that the teacher is like a conductor of an orchestra or a director of a drama. As students engage in their rehearsed or spontaneous language performance, it is your job to keep the process following smoothly and efficiently. The ultimate motive of such direction, of course, must always be to enable students eventually to engage in the real-life drama of improvisation as each communicative event brings its own uniqueness.
Thirdly, teacher as manager. This metaphor captures your role as one who plans lessons, modules, and curses, and structures the largest, longer segments of classroom time, but who then allows each individual player to be creative within those parameters. Managers of successful corporations, for example, retain control of certain larger objectives of the company, keep employees pointed toward goals, engage in ongoing evaluation and feedback, but give freedom to each person to work in his or her own individual areas of expertise. A language class should not be markedly different.
Fourthly, teacher as facilitator. A less directive role might be described as facilitating the process of learning, of making learning easier for students: helping them to clear away roadblocks, to find shortcuts, to negotiate rough terrain. The facilitating role requires that you step away from the managerial or directive role and allow students, with your guidance and gentle prodding, to find their own pathway to success. A facilitator capitalizes on the principle of intrinsic motivation by allowing students to discover language through using it pragmatically, rather than by telling them about language.
Finally, teacher as resource. This is the less directive role. In fact, the implication of the resource role is that the student takes the initiative to come to you. You are available for advice and counsel when the student seeks it. It is of course not practical to push this metaphor to an extreme where you would simply walk into a classroom and say something like, “Well, what do you want to learn today?” Some degree of control, of planning, of managing the classroom is essential. But there are appropriate times when you can literally take a back seat and allow the students to proceed with their own linguistic development.
In almost the same way, Harmer (2007: 23-24) states that when we walk into lesson, students get an idea of who we are as a result of what we look like (how we dress, how we present ourselves) and the way we behave and react to what is going on. They take note, either consciously or subconsciously, of whether we are always the same or whether we can be flexible, depending on what is happening at a particular point in the lesson.
Teachers, like any other group of human beings, have individual differences. However, one of the things, perhaps, that differentiates us from some other professions, is that we become different people, in a way, when we are in front of a class from the people we are in other situations, such as at home or at a party. Everyone switches roles like this in their daily lives to some extent, but for teachers, who we are (or appear to be) when we are at work is especially important.” So, who teachers are in the class depend on personality, adaptability, and teacher roles.
He also acknowledges that our physical presence can play a large part in our management of the classroom environment. And it’s not just appearance either (though that was clearly an issue for the secondary student). The way we move and stand, and the degree to which we are physically demonstrative can have a clear effect on the management of the class. Most importantly, the way we are able to respond to what happens in class, the degree to which we are aware of what is going on, often marks the difference between successful teaching and less satisfactory lessons (pages 34-36).
All teachers, like all people, have their own physical characteristics and habits, and they will take these into the classroom with them. But there are a number of issues to consider which are not just matters of personality or style and which have a direct bearing on the students’ perception of us. hose issues are proximity, appropriacy, movement, and awareness.
Feez and Joyce (2002: 21-35) in Text-Based Syllabus Design when discussing “the process of learning language is a series of scaffolded developmental steps which address different aspects of language” assert that the methodology applied within the genre approach is based on the work of the Russian psychologist Vygotsky (1934/1978) and the American educational psychologist Bruner (1986). Vygotsky proposed that, in any given area of skills, knowledge or understanding, each learner has two levels of development: a level of independent performance, and a ‘level of potential performance’ which is made possible through social interaction and joint construction with ‘more capable others’ such as parents or teachers.
The gaps between these two levels Vygotsky called ‘the zone of proximal development’. A learning model based on Vygotsky’s concepts of development suggests two things about language learning: (a) If a teacher is only concerned with what students can already do with language ie with their existing level of independent performance, then the students will never progress and (b) If a teacher supports students so that they move through the zone of proximal development to their potential level of performance, real learning and progress is possible.
This model also suggests that input alone is not enough for students to reach their potential. Vygotsky proposes that learning is a collaboration between teacher and student with the teacher taking on an authoritative role similar to that of an expert supporting an apprentice. He points out that this collaboration always involves language in the form of a dialogue between teacher and student. Bruner (1986: 74) used the term scaffolding to describe the teacher’s role in the learning collaboration.
Through joint construction the teacher and the student develop texts together and share the responsibility for performance until the student has the knowledge and skills to perform independently and with sole responsibility. And, through scaffolding the teacher provides support for the students. This is done by providing explicit knowledge and guided practice. The teacher explicitly contributes what students are not yet able to do or do not know and adjusts the contribution as students move through the zone of proximal development towards their potential level of independent performance.
Hoi YHoi et al (2008: 143-156) when conducted a study entitled Teachers of Gifted Students in Hong Kong: Competencies and Characteristics report that their study was successful in exposing about the significant differences in all desired characteristics and competencies, except for competency in counseling. They concluded that overall, the results of their study may indicate that in-service teachers who have received some kind of training in teaching gifted students benefit by having higher desirable characteristics and competencies than their counterparts who have not received any training at all in this area.
Kwok-lun and Lew (1981) in their paper “The Criteria of Teacher Competence as Perceived by Students, Student-Teachers and Serving Teachers in Hong Kong” state that research on teacher competence has been an important subject of inquiry in education. For years, educators are concerned with the qualities of teacher essential to effective teaching and learning. Yet findings in this area have been inconclusive. Without knowing the criteria of good teaching, teachers have to judge their performance by experience.
Reddy and Sujathamalini (2005) in their study about “Awareness, Attitude and Competencies of Normal School Teachers” argue that the success of inclusive education programs to the disabled children to a large extent depends on the teachers’ awareness, attitude and competencies to deal children who are differently able in the regular classroom. The organizational, teaching & learning and guidance & counseling activities should be tuned to meet the individual need of the learners. It is natural that awareness leads to formation of better attitudes and in turn they transform into better competencies.
As the study clearly reveals that there is a positive significant correlation between awareness & attitude, awareness & existing competencies, and attitude & existing competencies of the normal school teachers, there is a need to integrate the awareness, attitude and competency development programs in one umbrella by involving print as well as electronic media. Audio and video cassettes can be developed on different aspects of disabilities such as concept of disabilities, etiology of disabilities, ways and means of identification & assessment, development of educational programs keeping in mind the strengths and weaknesses of disabled children, providing guidance & counseling appropriately to the parents and children with disabilities. Such audio and video cassettes can be supplied to all the normal schools and teacher training institutions.
Smith (2005) in his paper “Fifty-One Competencies for Online Instruction” acknowledges that the effectiveness of distance learning must be measured in results—quality learning. Learner-center programs and competent instructors are two oft-cited keys to success in higher education. Teaching online requires specific skill sets (competencies).
Malik et (2003: 521-523) in their study “Identification of University Teachers Competencies as Perceived by the Students” found out that as the result of survey, it was revealed that a majority of respondents were well aware of the attributes of a good teacher. However, most of them were not satisfied with regard to the possession of qualities like competencies in subject matter, teaching techniques, understanding of human psychology and behavior free from all types of prejudice. In the circumstances, it is recommended that short term teachers training program be made compulsory for all the University teachers especially the fresh entrants. It must contain aspects like teaching methodology, educational psychology, use of audio-visual aids, evaluation techniques etc.
Veilleux & Bournot-Trites (2005: 487-507) in their research “Standards for the Language Competence of French Immersion Teachers: Is There a Danger of Erosion?” try to examine standards used by Canadian universities and British Columbia school districts to verify the language competence of French Immersion (FI) teachers in a time of teacher shortage, confirmed by 56 per cent of school districts surveyed. They argue that there is no guarantee for this level of teachers’ competence because of heterogeneity in universities and school districts language measures and lack of validity and reliability for many of those measures. This may result in lowering teaching quality in FI programs.
education in FI schools and the success of the program.
Sa’ari, et al (2005: 1144) in their research “Attitudes and Perceived Information Technology: Competency among Teachers” aiming at measuring teachers’ attitudes and perceived competency towards information technology (IT). The results revealed that most teachers possess positive attitudes towards IT. The findings also established that most teachers have moderate levels of IT competency. They also believe that they still lack the appropriate IT skills to integrate the technology into the teaching and learning process.
Their research reveals that several positive attitudes toward new technologies. They seem to find IT more useful and have greater confidence, lower levels of anxiety and aversion toward using computers. This shows that teachers are proactive in today’s challenge where IT plays a part in the education system. Teachers’ attitudes must always be commensurate with the right attitude needed to face the current technology, which always evolves without limitations.
In fact, and this might become a general truth, that there is a need for teachers to improve their skills through frequent use, and practice, in order for them to successfully use any technology in teaching. This is because there is no reason to believe that the technology evolution will stop. Therefore, training programs must be added, removed or revised, as new technologies evolve.
Education is always concerned with the development of the potential of individuals for the future, not only among students but also among teachers. Therefore, teachers must understand that learning how to use computers does not play a part only in accumulating knowledge and new skills, but also that a greater part of learning is the result of trial-and-error endeavors in normal life. Therefore, teachers ought to have the courage to try new skills without apprehension, so that they are able to act as agents of change to fulfill the national aspirations enunciated in the philosophy of Malaysian education.
Fitzsimons (1997) in his research THE GOVERNANCE OF TEACHER COMPETENCY STANDARDS IN NEW ZEALAND underlines that competency standards for teachers have re-emerged as an issue for education. Their purpose has been asserted as: assisting in the governance of education; legitimating the system; improving the standard of pupil achievement and the quality of learning; improving the quality of teaching; raising the standard of teacher education; and promoting teaching as a profession.
Teacher’s voice and body language
Brown (2001: 192-206) when talking about “Classroom Management” asserts that classroom management encompasses an abundance of factors ranging from how you physically arrange the classroom, to teaching ‘styles’. In other words, it covers the physical environment of the classroom, teacher’s voice and body language, Unplanned teaching: Midstream lesson changes, teaching under adverse circumstances, teacher’s roles and styles, and creating a positive classroom climate. This paper just presents two of them: teacher’s voice and body language and teacher’s roles and styles.
He acknowledges that one of the first requirements of good teaching is good voice projection. We do not have to be aloud, booming voice, but we need to be heard by all the students in the room. When we talk, project our voice so that the person sitting farthest away from we can hear you clearly. If we are directing comments to a student in the row sitting right in front of us, remember that in a whole-class work, all the rest of the students need to be able to hear that comment. As we speak, articulate clearly; remember, these students are just learning English, and they need every advantage they can get.
Our voice is not the only production mode available to you in the classroom. Nonverbal messages are very powerful. In language classes, where students may not have all the skills they need to decipher verbal language, their attention is drawn to nonverbal communication.
Another thing teacher should consider is cultural expectations. Adapted from Hofstede (1986), Brown (2001) asserts that western cultures emphasize non-directive, nonauthoritarian roles and teaching styles in the right-hand column in the list above. One major consideration, therefore, in the effectiveness of playing roles and developing styles is the culture in which our are teaching and the culture of our students.
The Good Language Teachers
Brown (2001: 429-430) believes that one best way to begin setting goals and priorities is to consider the qualities of successful language teachers. Numerous “experts” have come up with their lists of attributes, and they all differ in a variety of ways. The eight foals for continuing career growth cited at the beginning of this chapter are one example of a list of attributes of a “good’ language teacher.
Harold B. Allen (1980) in Brown (2001) once offered the following down-to-earth list of characteristics of good ESL teachers: (1) Competent preparation leading to a degree in TESL, (2) A love of the English language, (3) Critical thinking, (4) The persistent urge to upgrade oneself, (5) Self-subordination, (6) Readiness to go the extra mile, (7) Cultural adaptability, (8) Professional citizenship, and (9) A feeling of excitement about one’s work.
According to him, those nine items contain a good deal of grist for the professional growth mills. How would we rate ourselves on all nine? Any room for improvement on any of them? If so, we have some goal-setting to do.
Harmer (2007: 51-53) in “How to Teach English” when talking about “Elements of Successful Language Learning (ESA)” argues that most current language teaching tries to offer a judicious blend of many of the ideas and elements. It recognizes the value of language exposure through comprehensible input, while still believing that most people (apart from young children) find chances to concentrate on language forms and how they can be used extremely helpful.
Current language teaching practice generally gives students the opportunity to think about how a piece of grammar works (or which words grow together, for example), while at the same time providing opportunities for language use in communicative activities and task-based procedures. It offers students the security of appropriate controlled practice (depending on variables such as the students’ age, personal learning styles and the language in question), while also letting them have a go at using all and any language they know.

Conclusion and Suggestion
What I mean by teacher competence here is an intellectual potency that exists in teacher’s mind and which is realized in doing his/her job professionally. It indicates that teacher competence refers to the ability of teacher to help, guide, and counsel his/her students so that his/her students can get good achievement.
In reality, to get good competence is an easy task. While taking too much burden on teaching tasks at school, a teacher is sometimes faced with a lot of tasks outside his/her daily routines at home or other places. Again, this problem needs teacher competence to be able to solve it.
By understanding our competence and doing our job as teachers professionally, I think, the government has provided us a great chance to improve our salary. I suggest that let us do our job best. If not us, who; if not now, when.


References
Boardman, C. A. and Jia Frydenberg. 2002. Writing to Communicate: Paragraphs and Essays. second edition. New York: Pearson Education.
Brown. H. D. 2001. Teaching by Principles, An Interactive Approach to Language Pedagogy, Second edition. New York: Addison Wesley Longman, Inc.
Brumfit, C. and R. Mitchell (Eds). 1990. Research in the Language Classroom. HK: Modern English Publication – British Council.
Cameron, L. 2001. Teaching Languages to Young Learners. London: Cambridge University Press.
Champion, R. A. (Ed). 1969. Learning and Activation. Sydney: John Wiley & Sons.
Cohen, L. et.al. 2007. Research Methods in Education. sixth edition. New York: Routledge.
Feez, F. and Helen Joyce. 2002. Text-Based Syllabus Design. Sydney: National Centre for English Langage Teaching and Research, Macquarie University.
Fitzsimons, P. 1997. The Governance of Teacher Competency Standards In New Zealand. Australian Journal of Teacher Education, vol. 22, No. 2. http://ajte.education.ecu.edu.au/ISSUES/PDF/222/Fitzsimons.pdf. Retrieved on January 15, 2009.
Goh, C. C. M. and Rita Elaine Silver. Language Acquisition and Development. A Teacher’s Book. Singapore: Longman.
Harmer, J. 2007. How To Teach English. Second impression. China: Longman.
Johnson, M. 2004. A Philosophy of Second Language Acquisition. Mirmingham, New York: Vail Ballou Press.
Kwok-lun, C. and William J. F. Lew. 1981. The Criteria of Teacher Competence as Perceived by Students, Student-Teachers and Serving Teachers in Hong Kong. CUHK Education Journal Vol. 9, No. 1. http://sunzi1.lib.hku.hk/hkjo/view/33/3300112.pdf. Retrieved on January 15, 2009.
Malik, N. H. et al. 2003. Identification of University Teachers Competencies as Perceived by the Students. International Journal of Agriculture & Biology, 1560–8530/2003/05–4–521–522. http://www.ijab.org or http://www.fspublishers.org/ijab/past-issues/IJABVOL_5_NO_4/33.pdf. Retrieved on January 15, 2009.
Maum, R. 2002. Nonnative-English-Speaking Teachers in the English Teaching Profession. Online Resources: Digests. JCPS Adult and Continuing Education.
Omaggio, A. C. 1986. Teaching Language in Context, Proficiency-Oriented Instruction. Boston, Massachusetts, USA: Heinle & Heinle Publishers
Oshima, A. and Ann Hogue. 2006. Writing Academic English. Fourth edition. New York: Pearson Education, Inc.
Padwad, Amol and Krishna K. Dixit. 2008. Impact of Professional Learning: Community Participation on Teachers' Thinking about Classroom Problems. TESL-EJ. Volume 12, Number 3, 2008. Retrieved January 21, 2009
Reddy, L. and J. Sujathamalini. 2005. Awareness, Attitude and Competencies of Normal School Teachers. http://sell.hil.no/nndr2005/Papers-nndr/Sujathamalini%20-%20abstract%20og%20pap. Retrieved on January 15, 2009.
Richards, J. C. 2006. Communicative Language Teaching Today. First edition. Singapore: Cambridge University Press.
Sa’ari, J. S. et al. 2005. Attitudes and Perceived Information Technology Competency among Teachers. Malaysian Online Journal of Instructional Technology (MOJIT) Vol. 2, No. 3, pp 70-77 December. http://pppjj.usm.my/mojit/articles/pdf/Dec05/09%20-%20attitudes_and_perceived%5B1%5D-final.pdf. Retrieved on January 15, 2009.
Saleh, M. 2008. Enam Tradisi Besar Penelitian Pendidikan Bahasa. Cetakan Pertama. Semarang: UNNES Press.
Salkind, N. J. 1985. Theories of Human Development, second edition. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Strevens, P. 1977. New Orientations in the Teaching of English. London: Oxford University Press.
Trappes-Lomax, H (Ed). 2001. Theory in Language Teacher Education, second impression. Malaysia: Pearson Education Limited.
Veilleux, I. & Monique Bournot-Trites. 2005. Standards for the Language Competence of French Immersion Teachers: Is There a Danger of Erosion? Canadian Journal of Education 28, 3: 487-507 http://www.csse.ca/CJE/Articles/FullText/CJE28-3/CJE28-3-bournot.pdf. Retrieved on January 15, 2009.
Wray, A. et. Al. 1998. Projects in Linguistics, a Practical Guide to Researching Language. London, Great Britain: Arnold.
YHoi, et al. 2008. Teachers of Gifted Students in Hong Kong: Competencies and Characteristics. The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher 17: 2, pages 143-156, http://www.egyankosh.ac.in/bitstream/123456789/24676/1/Unit6.pdf or http://www.philjol.info/index.php/TAPER/article/viewPDFInterstitial/728/674. Retrieved on January, 15, 2009.

Read More...